Her Name in the Sky Review: Is It Worth Reading?

Verdict: A devastating, deeply felt YA story about a Catholic girl in Louisiana falling for her best friend, held back by a love interest many readers find hard to forgive and a long middle that hurts more than some can bear.

Best for: Readers who want an emotional coming-out story about faith and first love, who are ready to cry, and who don’t need the romance to be easy or the love interest to behave well.

Heat level: ★☆☆☆☆ (1/5: young adult, kisses only)

Rating: ★★★★☆ (4/5: a 4.26 Goodreads average across nearly 18,000 ratings, with a pointed minority report about Baker)

Tropes: Best friends to lovers, internalized homophobia, Catholic school, senior year, forbidden love, small friend group, coming out, faith crisis, sister bond, hopeful ending.

Her Name in the Sky is Kelly Quindlen’s first novel, self-published in 2014 and reissued by Roaring Brook Press in January 2026 with a new bonus chapter, and it’s a young adult forbidden love story set in a conservative Catholic community in Louisiana: Hannah wants an easy senior year of football games and Mardi Gras parties, and instead she’s falling for her best friend, Baker, while everything she’s been taught tells her she can’t.

It’s the most-read book in this batch by a long way, with a 4.26 Goodreads average across 17,804 ratings and 4.21 on StoryGraph across 4,764 reviews. Kirkus reviewed the 2026 edition warmly. But the low reviews aren’t scattered complaints. They aim at one character and one choice she makes, and both halves of that split are worth understanding before you start.

What Is Her Name in the Sky About?

This is a coming-of-age novel first and a romance second, and the religion is not background. Hannah has grown up in the church, she believes in it, and the book treats her faith with respect even as it shows the damage that faith’s rules are doing to her. That makes it heavier than the cover suggests and closer to character-driven fiction than to a YA rom-com.

Hannah is close to her friends and to her sister, and she’s very good at doing what’s expected. Baker is bolder, funnier and braver, the friend who cooks mac and cheese at midnight and believes in books. The story stays close to Hannah, so you feel every rule she’s trying to follow. There’s a kind boy, Wally, who likes her, and a friend, Clay, who likes Baker, and those two boys complicate everything.

What Makes This Sapphic YA Coming-Out Story Work

  • The faith struggle: The book’s treatment of being queer and Catholic is what readers praise most. Even a 2-star reviewer says she loved how the struggle in a Catholic community is portrayed.
  • The tears: Half the reviews on the first page of Goodreads mention crying. Readers say it wrecked them, and one says her therapist will be hearing about it.
  • Hannah’s inner life: Kirkus praises how Quindlen writes Hannah’s turmoil as she weighs what she was taught against what she feels, and readers say the same in plainer words.
  • The friend group: Readers like the senior-year world of parties, football and late-night talks, and at least one wants a book for two of the side characters.
  • Hope: For all the pain, hopeful is one of the top moods on StoryGraph, and readers say it ends somewhere good.

Book Synopsis

Hannah’s plan for senior year is simple. Football games, parties, spring break, and time with the same tight group of friends she’s had for years. Her sister keeps teasing her about Wally, the sweet, dependable boy who’s clearly interested, and Hannah knows that saying yes to Wally is what everyone expects.

The problem is Baker. Baker has been her best friend for four years, and lately Hannah can’t stop looking at her. She wants to hold her hand, make her laugh, hear what she’ll say next. Every time she catches herself, she hears the voice of her church, her school and her town, and she prays the feeling will go away. It doesn’t.

Then Clay, one of their friends, starts paying attention to Baker, and Hannah is supposed to be happy for them. Something has shifted between Hannah and Baker, and it might not be one-sided. But in a community where this is the one thing you can’t be, Hannah has to decide whether she’s brave enough to risk her friends, her family and her faith for a girl who sees her clearly.

My Review

What this book does best is take faith seriously. Hannah isn’t a girl who secretly never believed. She loves God, and that’s exactly why it hurts. Quindlen lets you sit inside that conflict for a long time, and readers who grew up religious keep saying it felt true to them.

Her Name in the Sky by Kelly Quindlen book cover

The emotional pull is its other strength, and it’s enormous. On StoryGraph, 94% of readers tag it emotional and 60% tag it sad. Reviewers write about sobbing, about joining the fandom for this couple, about a new favourite book. If you want a book to make you feel things, it will.

The criticism is focused, though, and it’s about Baker. The most detailed 1-star review says this isn’t really best friends to lovers, because after some kisses on the beach Baker drops the friend group, starts dating their mutual friend, shows affection to him in front of Hannah and ignores her messages. A 2-star reader says Baker doesn’t seem to care how badly she hurts Hannah and that Clay is a jerk Hannah forgives far too easily. A second 1-star reviewer hates Clay and Baker in equal measure. These aren’t the majority, but they’re loud and specific, and they’re about the romance itself.

The other complaint is how much pain there is. The same 2-star reader describes crying in agony all the way through and calls the book a horror show. One reader thought the writing was mediocre and felt characters changed personality to suit the plot. And at 400 pages in the new edition, it’s long for a YA romance, which makes the hard middle feel longer.

So set expectations. If you’re hoping for a soft, swoony best-friends romance, this isn’t it, and Baker may make you furious. If you want an honest book about faith, fear and first love that earns its hope, that’s exactly what this is.

My honest note: A painful, sincere coming-out story that a lot of readers will never forget, with a love interest some will never forgive. Bring tissues, and patience for Baker.

ElementIn Her Name in the Sky
Central relationshipHannah & Baker: Catholic school seniors and best friends for four years
Core tropesBest friends to lovers, internalized homophobia, forbidden love, coming out, faith crisis
SettingA conservative Catholic community in Louisiana, senior year of high school
Heat level1/5: young adult, kisses only
SeriesStandalone; the 2026 Roaring Brook Press edition adds a bonus chapter
Content notesGraphic homophobia, religious bigotry and lesbophobia; moderate alcohol use, bullying and outing; minor eating disorder, injury and violence

How Spicy Is Her Name in the Sky?

It isn’t. This is young adult fiction, and the physical side is kisses and the ache of wanting to touch someone. I didn’t find it on romance.io, which is normal for YA, since that database mostly covers adult romance. Based on the YA label and what readers describe, it’s 1/5.

The thing to prepare for isn’t heat, it’s homophobia: StoryGraph readers list homophobia, religious bigotry and lesbophobia as graphic content warnings, with outing and bullying close behind. For other faith-heavy sapphic YA at the same low heat, try The Lesbiana’s Guide to Catholic School or I Kissed Shara Wheeler, both at 1/5.

Who Should Read This Book?

You’ll likely love it if: you want a story about being queer and religious, you’re happy to cry, you like long, interior coming-of-age novels, and you can forgive a love interest for being scared.

You may want to skip it if: religious homophobia is hard for you to read, you need the love interest to treat the heroine well, you want a light romance, and 400 pages of angst sounds like too much.

In short: an emotional, faith-centred coming-out novel that’s worth the pain if you go in knowing how much there is.

What Readers Are Actually Saying (November 2026)

This book has had two lives. It built a word-of-mouth following as a self-published novel from 2014, and then, after She Drives Me Crazy made Quindlen a bestseller, Roaring Brook Press reissued it in January 2026 in hardcover and paperback with a foil jacket and a new bonus chapter. Kirkus reviewed the new edition and praised it as a genuine account of what it takes to unlearn growing up queer in the Catholic church. I couldn’t get into Reddit to see what the sapphic subs say. The audiobook has been around since 2017: Piper Goodeve narrates the Tantor edition, which runs 11 hours and 14 minutes, and a newer recording by Goodeve runs 11 hours and 54 minutes. A Tantor listing quotes a blogger who says she voices both the girls and the boys well enough that you always know who’s talking.

Prefer audio? Listen to Her Name in the Sky on Libro.fm, the audiobook shop that supports independent bookstores.

Why readers love it (according to the discourse): Crying comes up constantly, in about half the reviews I read, usually as praise. The portrayal of faith is next, with religion mentioned in most reviews, including one from a reader wary of religious fiction who says she was humbled by it. Then the friend group and the senior-year feeling. Even one of the harshest reviews praises the Catholic portrayal, which suggests the complaints are about the romance rather than the book’s central subject.

What readers argue about and complain about: Baker, above everything. The detailed negative reviews say she treats Hannah badly after their first kisses, dating Clay and shutting Hannah out, and some readers say that means this isn’t a true best-friends-to-lovers story. Clay is the second target, with readers calling him a jerk and finding Hannah too forgiving. Third: intensity. Some readers found the suffering relentless. A reader also criticises the prose and the characters’ consistency, though that’s one voice. The real split is whether Baker’s behaviour reads as fear in a hostile community or as cruelty, and readers land on both sides.

The standalone question worth asking first: It’s a complete standalone, and Quindlen has said the story has a happy ending; readers describe it as hopeful. If you finish it wanting something lighter from the same author, She Drives Me Crazy is her rivals-to-lovers rom-com and a very different mood.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does Her Name in the Sky have a happy ending?

Yes, a hopeful one. Kelly Quindlen has said the story ends happily, and readers describe the ending as hopeful after a painful middle.

Is Her Name in the Sky a romance or a coming-of-age novel?

Both, but coming-of-age comes first. The romance with Baker drives it, and Hannah’s struggle with her faith is the heart of it.

How spicy is Her Name in the Sky?

Not at all. It’s young adult and stays at kisses, so 1/5.

What is new in the 2026 edition?

Roaring Brook Press reissued it in January 2026 with a new bonus chapter and a foil jacket, at about 400 pages.

Is there a Her Name in the Sky audiobook?

Yes. Piper Goodeve narrates, and the original Tantor recording runs 11 hours and 14 minutes.

If You Loved Her Name in the Sky, Read These Next

For another Catholic school story with more humour and less pain, try The Lesbiana’s Guide to Catholic School. The Miseducation of Cameron Post takes religious conservatism somewhere darker, and I Kissed Shara Wheeler sets a queer love story in a Christian school with a much lighter touch. For more love that isn’t supposed to happen, see our forbidden lesbian love books, or browse all our book reviews.

The Bottom Line

Her Name in the Sky sets out to show what it costs to be queer in a community built on faith, and it does that with real feeling. Hannah’s inner life is vivid, the Catholic setting is handled with care, and the emotional payoff is strong enough to make thousands of readers cry. Baker is hard to love for long stretches, the middle is painful and long, and a few readers think the writing is rough. If you want an honest, aching coming-out story with a hopeful end, it’s well worth reading. Check Her Name in the Sky on Amazon

The Eikna Overall Ranking

On the Eikna scale, Her Name in the Sky ranks as a landmark faith-and-coming-out YA novel. It’s powered by its honesty about religion and its emotional weight, held back by a love interest who divides readers, and best read for Hannah’s journey rather than for a swoony romance.

The Evidence Scorecard

Overall ★★★★☆ 4/5

  • ✓ 4.26 average across 17,804 Goodreads ratings
  • ✓ StoryGraph at 4.21 across 4,764 reviews
  • ✓ Kirkus reviewed the 2026 edition
  • ✓ Loud minority report about Baker

Romance ★★★★☆ 3.8/5

  • ✓ Longing written with real ache
  • ✓ Best friends of four years
  • ✓ Baker dates Clay and shuts Hannah out
  • ✓ Not true friends to lovers, say critics

Characters ★★★★☆ 4.1/5

  • ✓ Hannah interior life praised by Kirkus
  • ✓ A side couple one reader wants a book for
  • ✓ Clay widely disliked
  • ✓ Personalities shift to suit plot, says one

Writing ★★★★☆ 3.9/5

  • ✓ Prose called powerful by fans
  • ✓ Faith handled with care
  • ✓ Long at about 400 pages
  • ✓ Called mediocre by one reader

Emotional Impact ★★★★★ 4.6/5

  • ✓ 94% tag it emotional on StoryGraph
  • ✓ Crying in half the reviews I read
  • ✓ Religion and fear feel real
  • ✓ Relentless for some readers

Heat Level ★☆☆☆☆ 1/5

  • ✓ Young adult
  • ✓ Kisses only
  • ✓ No romance.io entry, normal for YA
  • ✓ Graphic homophobia is the real warning

Ending ★★★★☆ 4.1/5

  • ✓ Hopeful, per readers
  • ✓ Author says it ends happily
  • ✓ Standalone, nothing left hanging
  • ✓ 2026 edition adds a bonus chapter

Re-read Value ★★★★☆ 3.7/5

  • ✓ Piper Goodeve audiobook, 11h 14m
  • ✓ New bonus chapter for returning fans
  • ✓ Heavy middle to revisit
  • ✓ She Drives Me Crazy as a lighter follow-up

Find it on AmazonListen on Libro.fmListen with AudibleBuy at Bookshop.org

The store links on this page are affiliate links: we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Leave a Comment