Verdict: A light, funny middle grade novel about an eighth grader cast as Romeo opposite the new girl she has a crush on, with a bisexual heroine and a smart way into Shakespeare, held back by a middle that drags for some readers and adults who barely function.
Best for: Readers aged about 9 to 13 who like school-play stories, gentle humor and a first crush on a girl, especially kids who are just meeting Romeo and Juliet.
Heat level: ★☆☆☆☆ (1/5: middle grade, a crush only)
Rating: ★★★★☆ (3.8/5: a 4.15 Goodreads average across about 2,500 ratings and 4.16 on StoryGraph, trimmed for a recurring “cute but slow” complaint)
Tropes: School play, Shakespeare retelling, new girl, bisexual awakening, first crush, friendship drama, middle school, theater kids.
Star-Crossed is Barbara Dee’s 2017 middle grade novel from Aladdin: a contemporary school story inspired by Romeo and Juliet, in which Mattie, a star student and big reader, ends up playing Romeo in the eighth grade production opposite Gemma Braithwaite, the brilliant, outgoing and very British new girl she has a crush on.
It’s a quieter favorite than some sapphic middle grade books, with about 2,500 Goodreads ratings at 4.15 and 912 on StoryGraph at 4.16. Readers praise it for giving young readers a bisexual heroine without fuss. The complaints are about pace and plausibility, not the representation.
What Is Star-Crossed About?
It’s a light school story with a play at its heart. Rehearsals give the book its structure, and Shakespeare’s lines keep echoing Mattie’s own feelings. The tone is mostly funny and hopeful, with some middle school drama along the way.
Mattie has had a crush on a boy before, and the book makes clear she still could. Now she’s falling for Gemma, and she has to figure out what that means while learning to play the lovestruck Romeo on stage. She narrates, so you get her nerves and her jokes directly.
What Makes This Sapphic Middle Grade Novel Work
- Bisexual representation for kids: Readers are thrilled to see a young bisexual character, written without being sexualized or turned into a lesson.
- Shakespeare made fun: One reader says she understood the play better from this book than from university courses.
- Lighthearted: StoryGraph’s top moods are lighthearted (81%) and funny (62%).
- Mattie: Readers like the narrator, a smart reader who loves words.
- The theater setting: Rehearsal chaos and backstage drama give it a cozy, familiar energy.
Book Synopsis
Mattie loves books, school and words, so she’s thrilled when her English teacher announces that the eighth grade will stage Romeo and Juliet. She’s even more thrilled, and terrified, when a string of events lands her the role of Romeo.
Her Juliet is Gemma Braithwaite, the new girl: brilliant, pretty, outgoing and British. Mattie can’t stop thinking about her, and playing Romeo means saying Shakespeare’s most famous love lines to the girl she has a crush on.
As rehearsals go on, Mattie has to sort out how she feels, deal with friends and classmates who have opinions and figure out whether she’s brave enough to be honest, on stage and off.
My Review
The concept is clever and the execution is warm. Using Romeo and Juliet as a mirror for a young girl’s first crush on another girl gives the book a natural shape, and Dee makes Shakespeare feel accessible and fun rather than homework.
The second strength is how calmly it treats Mattie’s bisexuality. She has liked a boy, she now likes a girl and the book doesn’t make a crisis of it. Several readers, including bisexual adults, say how refreshing that is.
Where it struggles is pacing and the adults. Two StoryGraph readers rated it 2.5 stars: one says it dragged hard unless you love Shakespeare, the other found it boring with flat characters. Another reader was furious that every adult in the book seems useless. A two-star Goodreads reviewer felt underwhelmed by the end, and one reader admits rolling her eyes at the middle school drama. About 4% of Goodreads ratings are one or two stars.
My honest note: A sweet, clever school story with lovely bisexual representation and a slow middle. Great for theater kids and Shakespeare beginners.
| Element | In Star-Crossed |
|---|---|
| Central relationship | Mattie, cast as Romeo, and Gemma Braithwaite, the new girl playing Juliet |
| Core tropes | School play, Shakespeare retelling, new girl, bisexual awakening, first crush |
| Setting | An eighth grade staging of Romeo and Juliet |
| Heat level | 1/5: middle grade |
| Series | Standalone |
| Content notes | Bullying (moderate, per StoryGraph); homophobia, vomiting (minor) |
How Spicy Is Star-Crossed?
It’s middle grade, so 1/5: a crush and stage-acting nerves, nothing more. I didn’t check romance.io, which covers adult romance.
The content warnings are light: StoryGraph lists bullying as moderate, with homophobia and vomiting as minor. For a more emotional sapphic middle grade story, try Ivy Aberdeen’s Letter to the World.
Who Should Read This Book?
You’ll likely love it if: you love theater and school stories, you want a bisexual heroine for a young reader, Shakespeare interests you, you like light, funny books.
You may want to skip it if: slow middles bore you, clueless adults annoy you, you want a big emotional story, middle school drama grates on you.
In short: A charming, light Shakespeare story with a quietly important heroine.
What Readers Are Actually Saying (November 2026)
This book reaches readers through schools, libraries and lists of LGBTQ+ middle grade books. One Goodreads reviewer found it through a Tumblr post by the author’s daughter about coming out, which tells you something about why it was written. I couldn’t reach Reddit from here.
Why readers love it (according to the discourse): The bisexual representation, first. Then the clever Shakespeare framing and the humor. Readers call it cute, funny, clever and important, and say books like it are needed.
What readers argue about and complain about: Pacing (it drags for some), flat or useless adults and an underwhelming ending for at least one reader. There isn’t a deep split. Most readers like it; some find it too slow.
The standalone question worth asking first: It’s a standalone. Barbara Dee has written several other middle grade novels.
I couldn’t find an audiobook on Libro.fm.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Star-Crossed a sapphic book?
Yes. Mattie, who has liked a boy before, develops a crush on Gemma, the new girl. It’s a bisexual awakening story for middle grade readers.
What age is Star-Crossed for?
It’s middle grade. Mattie is in eighth grade.
Do you need to know Romeo and Juliet?
No. The book explains the play as it goes, and readers say it made Shakespeare easier to understand.
Is there an audiobook?
I couldn’t find one on Libro.fm.
If You Loved Star-Crossed, Read These Next
The Mighty Heart of Sunny St. James is another middle grade story about a girl whose plans to kiss a boy change when she meets a girl. Ivy Aberdeen’s Letter to the World is more emotional. And Ellie Engle Saves Herself adds superpowers to the first crush. More on our sapphic middle grade books list, and the full archive is under Book Reviews.
The Bottom Line
Star-Crossed wants to use Shakespeare to tell a gentle story about a first crush on a girl. The concept is clever, Mattie is likable and the bisexual representation is a real gift. The middle drags, the adults are thin and the ending is quiet. For a theater-loving young reader, it’s a lovely pick. Check Star-Crossed on Amazon.
The Eikna Overall Ranking
On the Eikna scale, Star-Crossed ranks as a charming mid-to-upper-tier sapphic middle grade novel. It’s light and clever, held back by pacing. Read it for the play and for Mattie.
The Evidence Scorecard
Overall ★★★★☆ 3.8/5
- ✓ 4.15 average across about 2,500 Goodreads ratings
- ✓ 4.16 on StoryGraph from 912
- ✓ About 4% one- or two-star ratings
- ✓ “Cute but slow” is the main complaint
Romance ★★★★☆ 3.6/5
- ✓ First crush on the new girl
- ✓ Romeo and Juliet framing is clever
- ✓ Fits the age range
- ✓ Crush only
Characters ★★★★☆ 3.7/5
- ✓ Mattie is a likable narrator
- ✓ Bisexuality treated calmly
- ✓ Gemma is vivid
- ✓ Adults called useless
Writing ★★★★☆ 3.8/5
- ✓ Funny, light voice
- ✓ Shakespeare made accessible
- ✓ Rehearsal scenes lively
- ✓ Middle drags for some
Emotional Impact ★★★★☆ 3.6/5
- ✓ Top moods: lighthearted and funny
- ✓ Hopeful tone
- ✓ Representation matters to readers
- ✓ Lower stakes than similar books
Heat Level ★☆☆☆☆ 1/5
- ✓ Middle grade
- ✓ A crush only
- ✓ No romance content
- ✓ Descriptive score, not a criticism
Ending ★★★★☆ 3.6/5
- ✓ Opening night payoff
- ✓ Standalone
- ✓ Hopeful close
- ✓ Underwhelming for at least one reader
Re-read Value ★★★★☆ 3.6/5
- ✓ Great for theater kids
- ✓ Pairs with studying the play
- ✓ Quick read
- ✓ No audiobook found
Find it on AmazonListen on Libro.fmListen with AudibleBuy at Bookshop.org
The store links on this page are affiliate links: we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
