This Delicious Death Review: Is It Worth Reading?

Verdict: A gory, campy YA horror about four ghoul girls at a desert music festival, with a sweet bi best-friends-to-lovers romance and a premise straight out of Jennifer’s Body, let down by horror that many readers found too tame and storytelling that tells more than it shows.

Best for: Teen and adult YA readers who want queer, gross, funny horror with a festival setting and a soft romance underneath, and who don’t need real scares.

Heat level: ★☆☆☆☆ (1/5: YA, kissing level)

Rating: ★★★☆☆ (3.4/5: a 3.55 Goodreads average across nearly 13,000 ratings and 3.66 on StoryGraph, trimmed for a recurring “fun premise, bland execution” complaint)

Tropes: Best friends to lovers, flesh-eating girls, festival gone wrong, found family, pandemic aftermath, bi lead and trans bi love interest, YA horror, standalone.

This Delicious Death is Kayla Cottingham’s 2023 standalone from Sourcebooks Fire: a sapphic YA horror novel set three years after a pathogen turned a small share of humanity into ghouls who can only survive on human flesh, where four best friends head to a desert music festival for one last party before graduation and one of them goes feral on the first night.

The pitch is irresistible, and nearly 13,000 Goodreads ratings show how many readers bit. The reception is middling, though: a 3.55 average on Goodreads and 3.66 on StoryGraph. Fans call it the queer, flesh-eating friendship story they didn’t know they needed. Critics say it’s surprisingly safe for a book about cannibal girls. Both are worth hearing.

What Is This Delicious Death About?

It’s YA horror with a satirical edge. The world has a synthetic meat called SynFlesh that keeps most ghouls stable, and a society that still fears and resents them. The festival setting gives the book its party energy, and the gore arrives when that system breaks down.

Zoey, Celeste, Valeria and Jasmine are ghouls from Southern California, close friends about to graduate. Zoey narrates, and her feelings for Celeste, her best friend, drive the romance. The cast includes bisexual and trans characters, and readers note a cis bi lead and a trans bi love interest. When Val turns feral and then disappears, the friends have to find her before things get worse.

What Makes This Sapphic YA Horror Work

  • The premise: Flesh-eating girls at a Coachella-style festival is the hook, and readers who loved it say it delivers the campy, gory fun the Jennifer’s Body comparison promises.
  • Friendship: The four girls’ bond is the emotional core, and fans love the found-family feel.
  • Best friends to lovers: Zoey and Celeste’s romance is sweet and low-key, a soft center inside the gore.
  • Queer and trans representation: Readers point to a bi narrator and a trans bi love interest, written as ordinary parts of the story.
  • Fast: 53% of StoryGraph readers rate it fast-paced, and many finished it in a day.

Book Synopsis

Three years ago, melting Arctic permafrost released a pathogen that changed a small part of the population. People who caught it slowly lost the ability to eat normal food. To survive, they had to eat human flesh, and those who didn’t turned feral. Scientists eventually created a synthetic substitute, and life mostly went back to normal, except that everyone else now calls the changed ones ghouls and doesn’t trust them.

Zoey, Celeste, Valeria and Jasmine are ghouls, best friends and about to graduate. Their plan is simple: one last weekend at a music festival in the desert, with a cooler full of hard seltzer and SynFlesh. Zoey has another plan too, maybe, involving Celeste and feelings she hasn’t admitted.

Then, on the first night, Val goes feral, and by morning she’s gone. Something at the festival is very wrong. The girls have to find their friend in a crowd that would turn on them if it knew what they were, and figure out who, or what, is making ghouls lose control.

My Review

The concept is the star. Cottingham builds a clever world, with a synthetic flesh industry, an anxious public and a festival full of people who’d be prey if anything slipped. It’s funny and nasty in the right proportions, and when the gore arrives, it’s vivid. The author even opens with a warning about graphic content.

This Delicious Death by Kayla Cottingham book cover

The second strength is the friendship. The four girls feel like a real group, with history and in-jokes, and the romance between Zoey and Celeste grows out of that closeness rather than interrupting it. It’s a gentle love story inside a gross book, and fans love the contrast.

Where it struggles is execution, and that’s the dominant complaint. Several StoryGraph readers call it bland or boring, and one says it barely qualifies as horror and never pushes far enough. Another DNF’d over a serious case of telling instead of showing. A reader questions how lightly the book treats the ghouls’ past killings. Adult readers who didn’t realize it was YA were often disappointed by the voice. About 12% of Goodreads ratings are one or two stars, and some of those are plainly hostile to the book’s queer and trans characters rather than its craft, so I’ve discounted them.

The gap is in the marketing. “Jennifer’s Body fans” and a cooler of organs suggest something sharp and dangerous. What you get is closer to a YA friendship adventure with gore on top. Read it for fun and you’ll likely enjoy it. Go in expecting real horror and you’ll probably feel shortchanged.

My honest note: A fun, queer, gory romp with a sweet romance, more slumber-party horror than nightmare fuel. Great for a quick, campy read.

ElementIn This Delicious Death
Central relationshipZoey and her best friend Celeste, best friends to lovers
Core tropesBest friends to lovers, flesh-eating girls, festival gone wrong, found family
SettingA desert music festival in Southern California, after a ghoul pandemic
Heat level1/5: YA, kissing level
SeriesStandalone
Content notesCannibalism, gore and body horror (graphic, per StoryGraph); alcohol, confinement, vomiting; deadnaming, transphobia, suicidal thoughts

How Dark and Spicy Is This Delicious Death?

Spicy, no. It’s YA, so the romance stays at the kissing level, and I couldn’t reach romance.io (which mostly indexes adult romance anyway). I’d call it a 1/5.

Dark, yes, in the gross-out sense. StoryGraph readers list cannibalism, gore and body horror as graphic, and minor warnings include deadnaming, transphobia and suicidal thoughts. If you want sapphic horror with more bite, Gideon the Ninth is gorier and funnier, and The Stars Are Legion takes body horror much further.

Who Should Read This Book?

You’ll likely love it if: you want campy, gory YA horror, best-friends-to-lovers is your trope, you like queer and trans casts, you want a one-day read.

You may want to skip it if: you want real scares, YA voice bothers you, tell-don’t-show writing frustrates you, cannibalism and gore are hard lines.

In short: A gross, sweet, fast read that’s more fun than frightening.

What Readers Are Actually Saying (November 2026)

This came from an established YA author with a New York Times bestseller behind her, and the Jennifer’s Body comparison did a lot of work. It’s a favorite on queer horror lists, including our own lesbian horror books page, and it has a wide YA audience. I didn’t find trade reviews to cite, and I couldn’t reach Reddit from here.

Why readers love it (according to the discourse): The premise and the camp. Fans call it the queer, flesh-eating best-friends love story they didn’t know they needed, and praise the friendship, the romance and the representation. StoryGraph’s top moods are dark (69%) and mysterious (63%), with plenty of funny (44%).

What readers argue about and complain about: First, it’s not scary enough: readers call it bland and say it barely counts as horror. Second, craft: tell-don’t-show writing and a voice adult readers found young. Third, the world’s logic, including how easily the ghouls’ violence is forgiven. Some one-star reviews object to the book’s queerness itself, and I’ve set those aside. The real split is about expectations: YA readers looking for fun tend to rate it well, and horror readers looking for teeth don’t.

The standalone question worth asking first: It’s a standalone with a complete story. Cottingham’s other YA novels, like My Dear Henry, are separate books.

The audiobook from Recorded Books is narrated by Sophie Amoss and runs 8 hours and 30 minutes.

Prefer audio? Listen to This Delicious Death on Libro.fm, the audiobook shop that supports independent bookstores.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is This Delicious Death sapphic?

Yes. The romance is between Zoey and her best friend Celeste, both bisexual, and the cast includes trans characters. It’s a best-friends-to-lovers story.

Is This Delicious Death scary?

It’s gory more than scary. Many readers say it’s more fun than frightening, and some say it barely counts as horror.

Is This Delicious Death YA?

Yes. It’s published by Sourcebooks Fire as young adult, and some adult readers who missed that were disappointed by the voice.

Is there an audiobook?

Yes. Sophie Amoss narrates the Recorded Books edition, which runs 8 hours and 30 minutes.

If You Loved This Delicious Death, Read These Next

Gideon the Ninth has the gore, the jokes and the sapphic chaos at full strength. Labyrinth Lost is another YA story where a girl’s dangerous power and her best friend are tangled together. And for adult body horror without the camp, The Stars Are Legion goes much darker. More on our lesbian horror books list, and the full archive is under Book Reviews.

The Bottom Line

This Delicious Death wants to be queer, gory, campy fun with a sweet love story in the middle. The premise is great, the friendship is warm and the romance is lovely. The horror is mild, the writing tells too much and the world doesn’t hold up to close inspection. For a fast, gross, feel-good YA read, it hits the spot. Check This Delicious Death on Amazon.

The Eikna Overall Ranking

On the Eikna scale, This Delicious Death ranks as a fun, mid-tier sapphic YA horror. It’s campy and warm, held back by tame scares and telling over showing. Read it for the friendship and the gore, not for terror.

The Evidence Scorecard

Overall ★★★☆☆ 3.4/5

  • ✓ 3.55 average across nearly 13,000 Goodreads ratings
  • ✓ 3.66 on StoryGraph from about 4,800
  • ✓ About 12% one- or two-star ratings
  • ✓ Bland horror is the top complaint

Romance ★★★☆☆ 3.4/5

  • ✓ Sweet best-friends-to-lovers
  • ✓ Grows out of real closeness
  • ✓ Bi lead and trans bi love interest
  • ✓ Low-key and secondary to the plot

Characters ★★★☆☆ 3.4/5

  • ✓ Four-girl friendship feels real
  • ✓ Found-family warmth
  • ✓ Inclusive cast
  • ✓ Voice reads young to adults

Writing ★★★☆☆ 3.2/5

  • ✓ Fast, punchy pace
  • ✓ Vivid gore when it lands
  • ✓ Clever world setup
  • ✓ Tells more than it shows

Emotional Impact ★★★☆☆ 3.3/5

  • ✓ Friendship stakes matter
  • ✓ Finding Val drives tension
  • ✓ Moods: dark and mysterious
  • ✓ Never pushed far enough for some

Heat Level ★☆☆☆☆ 1/5

  • ✓ YA
  • ✓ Kissing level
  • ✓ No explicit content
  • ✓ Descriptive score, not a criticism

Ending ★★★★☆ 3.5/5

  • ✓ Complete standalone
  • ✓ Mystery resolved
  • ✓ Romance lands
  • ✓ Wraps up neatly

Re-read Value ★★★☆☆ 3.2/5

  • ✓ Quick, fun reread
  • ✓ 8 hour 30 minute audiobook
  • ✓ Good spooky-season pick
  • ✓ Little left to discover

Find it on AmazonListen on Libro.fmListen with AudibleBuy at Bookshop.org

The store links on this page are affiliate links: we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Leave a Comment