The Mermaid, the Witch, and the Sea Review: Is It Worth Reading?

The Mermaid, the Witch, and the Sea by Maggie Tokuda-Hall book cover

Verdict: A dark, beautifully written YA pirate fantasy with an anti-colonial heart and a starred Kirkus review, held back by a romance that falls into place too fast and a plot that tries to carry more than it can. Best for: Readers who want lyrical, fairy-tale prose, a queer-normative world, and a fantasy willing to … Read more

Fanged Secrets Review: Is It Worth Reading?

Fanged Secrets by Chloe Peterson book cover book cover

Verdict: A fast, spicy paranormal romance: Amara Leone, the deaf daughter of a ruthless mafia boss, is forced into an arranged marriage with Dylan Wood, a cold security chief her father wants her to spy on, who is secretly a vampire. Readers love the deaf representation, the chemistry and the action; a few found the … Read more

The Earl’s Wife Review: Is It Worth Reading?

The Earl's Wife by Jessica Dalvin book cover

Updated on October 6, 2026 Verdict: A quick, steamy, self-published historical about a betrothed woman falling for the female protector her father hires, held back by a predictable plot, a hazy sense of period and a second half that hands too much of the page to the men. Best for: Readers who want a short, … Read more

Consort of Fire Review: Is It Worth Reading?

Consort of Fire by Kit Rocha book cover

Updated on October 6, 2026 Verdict: A lush, very explicit F/F/M romantasy built on an established sapphic couple and a dragon god who is not what they were promised, held back by a thin plot that many readers say is mostly travel and sex. Best for: Readers who want romance-first, high-heat fantasy with a bisexual … Read more

Broken Vows Review: Is It Worth Reading?

Broken Vows by Nadine O'Keeffe and Scarlet King book cover

Updated on October 9, 2026 Verdict: A dark, very explicit Irish-gang enemies-to-lovers romance between a runaway bride and the enforcer sent to hunt her down, with a premise and a love interest readers enjoy, held back by an attraction that moves faster than many readers can believe and writing that some readers find rough. Best … Read more

Her Mafia Bride Review: Is It Worth Reading?

Her Mafia Bride by Persephone Black book cover

Updated on October 6, 2026 Verdict: A fast, steamy arranged-marriage mafia romance with an ice queen readers enjoy watching thaw, undercut by a rushed enemies-to-lovers turn, a heroine many readers find inconsistent and an ending that stops on a cliffhanger. Best for: Readers who want a short, high-heat sapphic mafia read with a commanding heroine … Read more

Giovanna Review: Is It Worth Reading?

Giovanna by Victoria Arrow – sapphic mafia romance book cover

Updated on October 6, 2026 Verdict: A propulsive, genuinely dark sapphic mafia debut with a butch heroine readers fall hard for and chemistry they call explosive, undercut by an age gap with a childhood history some readers cannot get past and an MF scene a sapphic-marketed book did not need. Best for: Readers who want … Read more