Straight Girl in My Bed Review: Is It Worth Reading?

Straight Girl in My Bed by Aurora North book cover

A one bed, friends to lovers wedding romance with a great premise and real heat, let down by continuity errors and a loud reader suspicion that it was AI-generated.

Melt With You Review: Is It Worth Reading?

Melt With You by Jennifer Dugan book cover

Jennifer Dugan’s YA ice cream truck road trip has a lovely premise and a Booklist star, but readers keep tripping over its miscommunication plot. Here’s what the evidence says.

Decking the Halls Review: Is It Worth Reading?

Decking the Halls by Hildred Billings book cover

Our evidence-led review of Decking the Halls by Hildred Billings, a spicy small-town sapphic Christmas novella about falling for your ex’s twin sister.

Party Favors Review: Is It Worth Reading?

Party Favors by Erin McLellan book cover

Our review of Party Favors by Erin McLellan, a very explicit sapphic New Year’s novella about online best friends sharing one bed: what readers love, what they skim, and who it’s for.

Say Yes to the Cheerleader Review — Is It Worth Reading?

Say Yes to the Cheerleader by Abby Crofton book cover

A sweet, low-stakes senior-year crush romance with no coming-out trauma — warm and gently funny, but held back by a thin cast and an abrupt ending.

Friday I’m in Love Review — Is It Worth Reading?

Friday I’m in Love by Camryn Garrett book cover

A Black bisexual teen throws herself a coming-out party in Camryn Garrett’s warm YA rom-com. Here is what 2,500+ readers say about the joy, the money story and the narrator who splits them.

The Afterward Review — Is It Worth Reading?

The Afterward by E. K. Johnston book cover

E.K. Johnston’s after-the-quest YA fantasy gives a knight and a thief a tender, happy-ending romance — but its split timeline loses many readers. Our evidence-led review.

The Dark Tide Review — Is It Worth Reading?

The Dark Tide by Alicia Jasinska book cover

Alicia Jasinska’s YA sapphic dark fantasy has a gorgeous drowning city and a queen worth reading, but most readers say the enemies-to-lovers romance arrives before it’s earned.