Witch’s Favor Review: Is It Worth Reading?
Is Witch’s Favor by Victoria Szalay worth reading? Our review of the sapphic dark fantasy prison-ship heist — the found family, the fade-to-black romance, and the cliffhanger.
Is Witch’s Favor by Victoria Szalay worth reading? Our review of the sapphic dark fantasy prison-ship heist — the found family, the fade-to-black romance, and the cliffhanger.
Verdict: A raw, spicy and messy sapphic story set in Toronto: Amy Love, an autistic Brit who uses sex to keep people at arm’s length, keeps colliding with anxious redhead Laura, the first woman she wants to stop making mistakes for. Readers praise the authentic neurodivergent perspective and heat; be warned it ends on a … Read more
Verdict: A well-written, emotionally intense YA opener about two teenage soccer players whose long-distance friendship becomes first love — knowledgeable about the sport and honest about hard things, but it is book one of six, and it ends somewhere painful. Readers who loved it went straight on to book two. Best for: Readers who want … Read more
Verdict: A short, steamy, funny lakeside romance between a heartbroken actress and an injured pro soccer player — well liked by series readers, but it is only half a story. It ends on a cliffhanger, and the relationship resolves in the next book. Best for: Readers already in the Lake Love series, or anyone happy … Read more
Updated on October 9, 2026 Verdict: A warm, funny found-family space adventure with one of the most lovable non-human characters in recent sapphic SFF, let down by low stakes, convenient plotting and a romance that stays in the background. Best for: Readers who want a cozy, character-first space story with a sapphic slow burn simmering … Read more
Updated on October 9, 2026 Verdict: A genuinely original what-happens-after-the-fairy-tale premise with a furious, morally grey Black sapphic heir at its centre, let down by a slow, exposition-heavy first half and a cliffhanger ending. Best for: Readers who want dark political fantasy with a difficult protagonist, who can wait half a book for the plot … Read more
Updated on October 8, 2026 Verdict: The only sapphic vampire romance where the throuple is genuinely a throuple rather than a couple with a guest, sold as a complete romance and ending on a cliffhanger the blurb never mentions. Best for: Readers who want a three-way relationship written with all three sides load-bearing, at the … Read more
Verdict: A sweeping, explicit sapphic western about a preacher’s daughter kidnapped from a train by a female outlaw — enormously beloved, genuinely rough around the craft edges, and it ends on a cliffhanger. Best for: Readers who want a captive-to-lover romance with real heat and a religious-trauma arc, and who are willing to start book … Read more
Updated on October 8, 2026 Verdict: An addictive, angsty age-gap romance between a 39-year-old protector and her 19-year-old step-niece, hiding from the mafia on a Montana estate — a taboo premise its fans devour and its critics cannot get past, with a mafia plot that barely matters and a cliffhanger ending. Best for: Readers who … Read more
Updated on October 8, 2026 Verdict: A short, steamy sapphic mafia romance with a great opening — a crime queen steals her brother’s bride from the altar — that most readers binge happily, held back by an age-gap backstory some readers cannot get past, prose that reminds many of Wattpad, and a cliffhanger that forces … Read more