If I Don’t Ask Review: Is It Worth Reading?

If I Don't Ask by E.J. Noyes book cover

Verdict: An aching, beautifully observed retelling of Ask, Tell from the closeted commanding officer’s side, and the highest-rated book in its series — limited only by the fact that it is a companion, not a starting point. Best for: Readers who have already loved Ask, Tell, who want pining, restraint and military-medical angst, and who … Read more

Out on Good Behavior Review: Is It Worth Reading?

Out on Good Behavior by Dahlia Adler book cover

Verdict: A sex-positive, tension-heavy college romance with a pansexual narrator and a genuinely clever abstinence-pact hook, held back by a thinly drawn love interest and a contrived late breakup. Best for: New adult readers who want an out, unapologetic queer heroine, a bad-girl/good-girl pairing built on slow-burning tension, and a short, fast campus romance. Heat … Read more

The Mermaid, the Witch, and the Sea Review: Is It Worth Reading?

The Mermaid, the Witch, and the Sea by Maggie Tokuda-Hall book cover

Verdict: A dark, beautifully written YA pirate fantasy with an anti-colonial heart and a starred Kirkus review, held back by a romance that falls into place too fast and a plot that tries to carry more than it can. Best for: Readers who want lyrical, fairy-tale prose, a queer-normative world, and a fantasy willing to … Read more

A Pirate’s Life for Tea Review: Is It Worth Reading?

A Pirate's Life for Tea by Rebecca Thorne book cover

Verdict: A cheerful, pun-heavy river adventure that doubles the sapphic couples and improves on book one in readers’ eyes, held back by low stakes, a baggy middle, and a main couple who spend much of the book watching someone else’s romance. Best for: Readers who loved Kianthe and Reyna in book one, who want a … Read more

Practical Rules for Cursed Witches Review: Is It Worth Reading?

Practical Rules for Cursed Witches by Kayla Cottingham book cover

Verdict: A warm, adventurous YA curse-breaking quest with a lovable airship found family and a sweet rivals-to-lovers romance, held back by a younger register and twists that readers see coming. Best for: Teen readers and adults who love cozy YA fantasy, who want found family as much as romance, and who are happy with kisses … Read more

Mortal Follies Review: Is It Worth Reading?

Mortal Follies by Alexis Hall book cover

Verdict: A witty, inventive Regency fantasy with a scene-stealing fae narrator and two starred trade reviews, held back by that same narrator keeping readers at arm’s length from the romance and a second half that loses momentum. Best for: Readers who love comedy-of-manners voice and Austen pastiche, who are happy to watch a romance through … Read more

Tapout Review: Is It Worth Reading?

Tapout by Nicole Disney book cover

Verdict: A gritty, Rocky-flavoured MMA romance that takes a supporting character from The Clinch into the world of underground fighting. Fans found it intense and impossible to put down; some felt Laila had changed too much from the first book or that the romance lacked spark. Best for: Readers who love fight scenes, underdog comebacks … Read more

Sparks Like Ours Review: Is It Worth Reading?

Sparks Like Ours by Melissa Brayden book cover

Verdict: A sunny, sexy rivals-to-lovers surfing romance with Melissa Brayden’s trademark banter, and for many readers the best of the Seven Shores series. A minority felt the formula was wearing thin and the romance didn’t quite spark. Best for: Readers who want witty dialogue, a beach setting and a feel-good competitor romance. Heat level: Hot … Read more

Schuss Review: Is It Worth Reading?

Schuss by E.J. Noyes book cover

Verdict: A sweet, low-angst new adult spin-off that gives Gold’s young side characters their own best-friends-to-lovers story. Fans enjoyed revisiting the family; many felt the teenage leads were less compelling than Gold’s couple and wished the story had been set years later. Best for: Readers who loved Gold and want a gentle coming-of-age romance. Heat … Read more

Full Court Crush Review: Is It Worth Reading?

Full Court Crush by Sasha Brennan book cover

Verdict: A warm, slow-burn debut about two teammates on a Welsh basketball team, with a sweet meet-cute, found family and a sizzling locker-room payoff. Readers enjoyed the heart and the UK setting; critics felt it juggled too many issues and lacked chemistry in places. Best for: Readers who want a cosy, low-miscommunication slow burn with … Read more