The Dos and Donuts of Love Review: Is It Worth Reading?

The Dos and Donuts of Love by Adiba Jaigirdar book cover

A pun-packed sapphic YA baking show novel with a proud fat, queer, Bangladeshi Irish heroine, held back by a romance that waits in the wings until late.

Planning Perfect Review: Is It Worth Reading?

Planning Perfect by Haley Neil book cover

Planning Perfect by Haley Neil is a warm, openly ace-spectrum YA wedding rom-com with real Jewish family texture, held back by a narrator many readers find hard to like and a romance that lands very late.

The Malign Ghosts of Summer Review: Is It Worth Reading?

The Malign Ghosts of Summer by Ann McMan book cover

Ann McMan’s sapphic historical novel has a found family readers adore and real emotional weight, but its short rotating chapters ask for patience. Here’s what the evidence shows.

The Christmas Swap Review: Is It Worth Reading?

The Christmas Swap by Talia Samuels book cover

Talia Samuels’ debut sapphic Christmas rom-com has a great fake-dating twist and a cozy country house, but readers say the chemistry is thin and the second half drags. Here’s what the evidence says.

The Sweetest Season Review: Is It Worth Reading?

The Sweetest Season by Harper Hayes book cover

Is The Sweetest Season by Harper Hayes worth reading? Our early review of this closed-door small-town sapphic slow burn, covering the heat, the counting and the series.

A Sweet Sting of Salt Review: Is It Worth Reading?

A Sweet Sting of Salt by Rose Sutherland book cover

A wintry, gothic selkie retelling set in 1830s Nova Scotia, with real menace and a tender closed-door love story, held back by a slow middle and a reveal readers see coming.

Say Yes to the Cheerleader Review: Is It Worth Reading?

Say Yes to the Cheerleader by Abby Crofton book cover

A sweet, low-stakes senior-year crush romance with no coming-out trauma — warm and gently funny, but held back by a thin cast and an abrupt ending.

This Ravenous Fate Review: Is It Worth Reading?

This Ravenous Fate by Hayley Dennings book cover

Black sapphic vampires in 1926 Harlem is a premise readers love. Our evidence-led review of Hayley Dennings’s YA debut weighs it against the editing, the pacing and an open ending.

How to Excavate a Heart Review: Is It Worth Reading?

How to Excavate a Heart by Jake Maia Arlow book cover

A funny, very Jewish sapphic YA winter-break romance with starred trade reviews and a scene-stealing corgi, undercut by a love story that skips most of the enemies phase it was sold on.