The Dos and Donuts of Love Review: Is It Worth Reading?
A pun-packed sapphic YA baking show novel with a proud fat, queer, Bangladeshi Irish heroine, held back by a romance that waits in the wings until late.
A pun-packed sapphic YA baking show novel with a proud fat, queer, Bangladeshi Irish heroine, held back by a romance that waits in the wings until late.
Planning Perfect by Haley Neil is a warm, openly ace-spectrum YA wedding rom-com with real Jewish family texture, held back by a narrator many readers find hard to like and a romance that lands very late.
Ann McMan’s sapphic historical novel has a found family readers adore and real emotional weight, but its short rotating chapters ask for patience. Here’s what the evidence shows.
Alexandra Benedict’s snowbound Christmas puzzle mystery has a bisexual heroine and a clever twelve-day game, but almost no romance and a killer most readers guess early.
Talia Samuels’ debut sapphic Christmas rom-com has a great fake-dating twist and a cozy country house, but readers say the chemistry is thin and the second half drags. Here’s what the evidence says.
Is The Sweetest Season by Harper Hayes worth reading? Our early review of this closed-door small-town sapphic slow burn, covering the heat, the counting and the series.
A wintry, gothic selkie retelling set in 1830s Nova Scotia, with real menace and a tender closed-door love story, held back by a slow middle and a reveal readers see coming.
A sweet, low-stakes senior-year crush romance with no coming-out trauma — warm and gently funny, but held back by a thin cast and an abrupt ending.
Black sapphic vampires in 1926 Harlem is a premise readers love. Our evidence-led review of Hayley Dennings’s YA debut weighs it against the editing, the pacing and an open ending.
A funny, very Jewish sapphic YA winter-break romance with starred trade reviews and a scene-stealing corgi, undercut by a love story that skips most of the enemies phase it was sold on.