Joy to the Girls Review: Is It Worth Reading?

Joy to the Girls by Rachael Lippincott and Alyson Derrick book cover

Joy to the Girls (UK: She Gets the Girl at Christmas) gives She Gets the Girl fans a cozy Christmas visit with Alex and Molly — but its secrets-and-miscommunication plot is the most repeated complaint in the reviews.

Make My Wish Come True Review: Is It Worth Reading?

Make My Wish Come True by Rachael Lippincott and Alyson Derrick book cover

A cosy sapphic YA Christmas fake-dating romance with a lovable town and a Hanukkah party, held back by 18-year-old leads who read like 25 and a heroine many readers struggle to forgive.

Witch’s Favor Review: Is It Worth Reading?

Witch’s Favor by Victoria Szalay book cover

Is Witch’s Favor by Victoria Szalay worth reading? Our review of the sapphic dark fantasy prison-ship heist — the found family, the fade-to-black romance, and the cliffhanger.

The Girl from the Sea Review: Is It Worth Reading?

The Girl from the Sea by Lee Knox Ostertag book cover

Is The Girl from the Sea by Lee Knox Ostertag worth reading? Our review of the sapphic selkie graphic novel — the 1/5 heat, the rushed romance, and the bittersweet ending.

The No-Girlfriend Rule Review: Is It Worth Reading?

The No-Girlfriend Rule by Christen Randall book cover

Verdict: A joyful, big-hearted YA debut about a fat, anxious teen finding her people at an all-girls tabletop game, with four starred reviews behind it, held back by a romance lighter than its marketing and more in-game play than some readers want. Best for: Teen and adult readers who want fat and mental-health representation done … Read more

Practical Rules for Cursed Witches Review: Is It Worth Reading?

Practical Rules for Cursed Witches by Kayla Cottingham book cover

Verdict: A warm, adventurous YA curse-breaking quest with a lovable airship found family and a sweet rivals-to-lovers romance, held back by a younger register and twists that readers see coming. Best for: Teen readers and adults who love cozy YA fantasy, who want found family as much as romance, and who are happy with kisses … Read more

I Kissed Shara Wheeler Review: Is It Worth Reading?

I Kissed Shara Wheeler by Casey McQuiston book cover

Verdict: A funny, warm, unapologetically queer YA mystery with one of the best friend groups in the genre, undercut by a title romance that a sizeable minority of readers find closer to obsession than love. Best for: Teen and adult readers who want a Southern-set queer coming-of-age story with a scavenger-hunt engine, who care about … Read more

Say Yes to the Soccer Player Review: Is It Worth Reading?

Say Yes to the Soccer Player by Abby Crofton book cover

Verdict: A cute, clean, low-stakes college romance about a girl who can’t talk to pretty girls and the soccer star who pursues her anyway. Series fans enjoy returning to the friend group; readers looking for tension or heat find very little to hold on to. Best for: Readers who want a sweet, PG sapphic campus … Read more

Fearless Review: Is It Worth Reading?

Fearless by Shira Glassman book cover

Verdict: A gentle, closed-door butch/femme short story about a newly out band mom and a butch orchestra director snowed in at a music competition, warm and easy to love but held back by a length that leaves readers wanting a whole book. Best for: Readers who want a low-angst romance between two women in their … Read more

Season of Love Review: Is It Worth Reading?

Season of Love by Helena Greer book cover

Updated on October 9, 2026 Verdict: A cozy-looking Christmas tree farm romance that is really a book about grief, sobriety and surviving an abusive father, with a fat butch lead readers cherish, held back by a romance that runs hot and cold and a closed door that leaves the chemistry half on trust. Best for: … Read more